Introduction: Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s much-awaited streaming debut, Heeramandi: The Diamond Bazar, has sparked a debate due to its portrayal of Lahore’s red-light district. Let’s delve into the critique of historical inaccuracies raised by a Pakistani viewer.
Viewer Critique: A Lahore-based viewer took to social media to highlight discrepancies in Heeramandi’s depiction of the 1940s era. From geographical misrepresentation to linguistic inaccuracies, the critique dissected various aspects of the show, including setting, language, songs, and costumes.
Geographical Misrepresentation: The viewer lamented the absence of Lahore’s essence in the show, pointing out discrepancies in architecture and landmarks. They emphasized the importance of authentically showcasing Heeramandi’s skyline, which prominently features the Shahi Qilla-Grand Mosque.
Linguistic Inaccuracies: Inaccurate portrayal of language was another point of contention, with the viewer highlighting the prevalence of Punjabi over Urdu in 1940s Lahore. They criticized the show’s dialogue delivery, which favored Urdu despite historical context suggesting otherwise.
Musical Representation: The viewer critiqued the show’s soundtrack, deeming it disconnected from the era. They argued that the selection of songs lacked authenticity, overlooking Punjabi masterpieces that were prevalent during the period.
Costuming Concerns: Bhansali’s penchant for elaborate costumes drew scrutiny, with the viewer questioning the authenticity of the attire. They criticized the glamorous portrayal of courtesans, highlighting the disparity between on-screen depiction and historical reality.
Conclusion: While Heeramandi: The Diamond Bazar promises an epic saga, its historical inaccuracies have sparked debate among viewers. The critique underscores the importance of thorough research and authenticity in portraying historical narratives, urging filmmakers to delve deeper into the essence of the era they seek to portray.
Comments